How I Evaluate a Student’s Reading Ability and English Skills

Here’s what a pharmacist from Egypt, who worked with me and achieved all the required scores, said recently:

“For the reading section, I remember I failed reading 3 times in the beginning, and I reached out to her to sign up for the reading package. During our first session, she has an amazing assessment class to know the student’s weaknesses and start working to improve them. I remember her words after our first session; she told me that I am really strong in reading and don’t need any tutoring for the reading section. And she was right. After that session, my average score in reading was 26-27, and I got 30 out of 30 4 times.”

How do I assess a student in the first reading class?

When working with TOEFL students, evaluating reading ability involves more than just checking answers. It requires a deep understanding of how a student’s brain processes language, retains information, and interprets complex ideas. To guide my students effectively, I assess both their reading strategies and their overall English language proficiency, helping them become strong, independent readers who can tackle challenging academic texts.


Step 1: Assessing Comprehension and Recall

The first thing I evaluate is whether the student can understand and remember key points after reading a passage. A strong reader can:

  • Identify the main idea and supporting details accurately.
  • Recall important facts without excessive rereading.
  • Explain how ideas are connected across the text.

Why It Matters: Comprehension and recall show whether the student can absorb information efficiently—a critical skill for success on the TOEFL exam.


Step 2: Evaluating Sentence Complexity and Understanding

TOEFL reading passages often include complex sentence structures, such as:

  • Compound and complex sentences: “Although the experiment was successful, the results were inconclusive due to measurement errors.”
  • Passive constructions: “The theory was widely accepted by the scientific community.”
  • Embedded clauses: “The book, which was published last year, received critical acclaim.”

What I Check:

  • Does the student break down complex sentences effectively?
  • Can they identify the subject, verb, and object clearly?
  • Are they struggling with specific grammar patterns?

Why It Matters: Strong readers can navigate advanced sentence structures without confusion, which is essential for TOEFL success.


Step 3: Evaluating Vocabulary Knowledge and Contextual Decoding

TOEFL reading passages are written at an advanced level, often using sophisticated vocabulary. I assess:

  • Range: How wide is the student’s vocabulary?
  • Depth: Can they understand nuanced word meanings and tone?
  • Contextual Skills: Do they use context clues effectively when encountering unfamiliar words?

Why It Matters: A strong reader can infer word meanings without relying on memorization, which helps them stay focused on the bigger message.


Step 4: Observing Information Processing Speed

Strong readers process information efficiently without losing accuracy. I observe:

  • How long does it take for the student to read a passage?
  • Are they rushing or overanalyzing?
  • Can they answer comprehension questions without repeatedly revisiting the text?

Why It Matters: Balancing speed and accuracy is essential for timed exams like the TOEFL.


Step 5: Identifying Reading Strategies and Cognitive Flexibility

A strong reader adapts strategies based on the task. I look for:

  • Does the student skim for main ideas when necessary?
  • Can they scan for specific details effectively?
  • Do they adjust their reading approach for different question types (e.g., factual vs. inference)?

Why It Matters: Cognitive flexibility allows students to handle various TOEFL question types with confidence.


Step 6: Evaluating Critical Thinking and Inference Skills

Many TOEFL questions require inference and higher-order thinking. I assess:

  • Can the student draw conclusions from subtle clues?
  • Do they understand the author’s purpose and viewpoint?
  • Are they able to answer rhetorical purpose questions accurately?

Why It Matters: TOEFL reading requires understanding both stated and implied meanings, so critical thinking is essential.


Step 7: Measuring Working Memory and Retention

Working memory helps students hold information while answering questions. I evaluate:

  • Can the student remember key ideas without constant rereading?
  • Do they retain important concepts while processing new details?

Why It Matters: Strong working memory supports both comprehension and test efficiency.


Step 8: Evaluating Metacognitive Awareness (Self-Monitoring)

Metacognition is the ability to think about one’s own thinking. I assess:

  • Does the student stop to clarify confusing parts?
  • Do they reflect on why they chose specific answers?
  • Are they aware when they don’t understand a section?

Why It Matters: Self-monitoring helps students catch misunderstandings early, leading to stronger reading habits.


Step 9: Handling Stress and Emotional Regulation During Reading

Emotional control plays a major role in performance. I assess:

  • Does the student stay calm under time pressure?
  • Do they avoid second-guessing their answers?
  • Can they recover from initial mistakes and stay focused?

Why It Matters: Stress can disrupt even strong readers. I work with students on strategies to stay composed and focused during the exam.


How I Use These Insights to Personalize Learning

By observing how a student processes reading and language, I can tailor strategies that match their specific needs. For example:

  • If a student struggles with complex sentences: I break down grammar structures and provide practice with simplified versions before moving to full texts.
  • If vocabulary gaps slow them down: I teach context-based guessing techniques and provide vocabulary-building activities.
  • If retention is an issue: I introduce note-taking strategies and encourage active reading habits.

Final Thought: Reading Skills Can Be Strengthened

A strong reader is not just someone who naturally excels—it’s someone who has developed skills in comprehension, critical thinking, and language mastery through practice and the right strategies. My goal is to help students strengthen these skills, empowering them to approach the TOEFL reading section with clarity, confidence, and success.

If you’re looking to improve your reading strategies and master complex texts for TOEFL success, let’s work together!

About LANGSOLUTION

Sherlen Tanner English Exam Coaching is your place to finally learn how to take the TOEFL test, achieve a 26+ in speaking, and learn the dynamics of accent reduction, TOEFL test-taking and TOEFL test-prep skills, reading, writing, and English language fluency and mastery all under the guidance of an exam coach and her team.